C:\UPSC\GS4\2021\Q-7.txt
Case Studies on Ethical DilemmasEXAMINEYear 202120 Marks
Concept / Statute•Directive•Institution / Stakeholder

Case Study: During the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic, you are the chief medical officer of a district hospital facing an acute shortage of medical oxygen. You have two patients requiring the last ventilator: Patient A is an 80-year-old retired freedom fighter and respected philanthropist, and Patient B is a 28-year-old daily-wage worker with a wife and three young children. The families and local community plead passionately for each. (a) Discuss the bioethical principles applicable to ventilator triage. (b) As the medical administrator, how will you decide and what is your ethical justification?

Exact Syllabus Pointer

Case studies on problems of integrity, conflict of interest, crisis management, political pressure, social boycott, ethical dilemmas in public office.

Connected Questions Across All Papers

Discovered through overlapping concepts: Ventilator Triage Dilemma, Bioethics in Pandemic, Utilitarian vs Deontological Triage

Recurring Theme Trend: “Ventilator Triage Dilemma”

6 questions across 14 yrs

Frequency of UPSC CSE Mains questions testing this core concept, landmark doctrine, or foundational syllabus theme (2013-2026)

20130
20141
20150
20161
20171
20181
20190
20200
20211
20220
20230
20240
20250
20261
HomeExploreSearchMy Vault